In an Age of Revolutions, in which everything seemed in transition, religion provided the tools through which to construct a consistent allegiance. STUDY. While this allegiance has led many critics to decry the apparent hypocrisy and opportunism among white evangelicals, it is just another example of how a certain brand of religiosity and American conservatism have become connected at the hip. A decade ago, it would have been difficult to conceive of Donald Trump as a key figure in America’s Christian image of itself. Nationalism - Nationalism - European nationalism: The first full manifestation of modern nationalism occurred in 17th-century England, in the Puritan revolution. As another respondent to Paine wrote, Christianity was “the most perfect standard of duty erected,” designed to “engage man to an endless progression in virtue” within the civic sphere. They ruled by democracy and endorsed capitalism. For America to succeed, then, they had to redouble their Christian alliance. Created by. An Ozarks Native Crosses the Show Me State. With the spread of nationalism in Europe during the 19th and 20th century many nations, like Germany and Italy, reasserted their power through unification under leaders like Bismarck. Nobody represented that threat more than Thomas Paine. After enduring unfair taxation without representation as well as restrictions on trade set in place by the British, American nationalism sprouted and led to the Boston Tea Party, or the start of the Revolutionary War. Match. American Nationalisms: Imagining Union in the Age of Revolutions, 1783-1833, The Long Road to White Christians’ Trumpism, Remembering the Right Rev. The United States of America was to be, beyond anything else, a Christian refuge from a fallen world. In this case, the enemy was Great Britain, its North American colonies in what is now Canada and many Native American nations. The American Revolution By the Enlightenment decades of the 1760s and 70s, the Lockean ideals of individual liberty and the people’s state had crossed the Atlantic to the American colonies, where they became the creed of the founding generation. It was first attributed to adherents of the revolutionary syndicalism and heavily promulgated by Benito Mussolini. The famed French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, for instance, looked to Moses as the premier example for turning a “national body” into “a political Body” that lived together with stability and peace. “That men destitute of religion, or the fear of God,” he concluded, “are unfit to lead and govern the important affairs of nations, [and] we have a recent and unhappy example in the late rulers of France, in her revolution.” America, due to its religious commitment, was a nation apart. The sectional nature of the antebellum northern vision of American nationalism has yet to be fully rectified with the narrower, but more specifically and politically defined, Union nationalism that was plainly evident during the war and at other moments of political crisis. Since all colonies bought similar goods, they managed to forge a common Anglican identity across colonial America. Michael Lind's book contains one excellent idea, and several well worth discussion. Since the end of the Cold War, however, the United States has abandoned enlightened nationalism in order to pursue permanent American global hegemony while preaching a … He is the author of American Nationalisms: Imagining Union in the Age of Revolutions, 1783-1833, from which this essay was adapted. The Great Awakening And Enlightenment In Colonial America. The Long Road to White Christians' Trumpism https://t.co/w35Q92mKe7. “It is necessary to be bold,” Paine explained to fellow skeptic Elihu Palmer, because while “some people can be reasoned into sense … others must be shocked into it.” In the introduction to Age of Reason, his popular and controversial pamphlet that attacked organized religion, he admitted his excitement over “the exceeding probability that a revolution in the system of government would be followed by a revolution in the system of religion.” The “circumstance that has now taken place in France,” he believed, would finally inaugurate a global transformation that would overturn priestcraft. At the war’s conclusion a French diplomat commented that “the war has given the Americans what they so essentially lacked, a national character.” Nationalism during colonial America meant to behave, dress and buy like the British. In Britain, Edmund Burke accused the French of tossing out their federally established religion that had served as a stabilizing feature of government. During the late seventeenth and early eighteen centuries, colonial America saw major changes. Likewise, in 1798, Samuel Spring warned his Newburyport, Massachusetts, congregation that America must avoid the influence of “French atheists” who were behind the chaos then spreading across the Atlantic. A Christian defense transcended the mere squabbles with Paine. He turned to the Enlightenment as a tool to imagine a future beyond nationalism. "Nationalism and the Great Revolutions" was written as an appendix to "Nationalism and the "National Question"." Religion was a central part of the equation. In the late 18th century, the American and French revolutions formalized large nations that were free of a monarchy. by William Norman Grigg Essentially, it indicates the aspects that characterize and distinguish the United States as an autonomous political community. Nationalism in the Americas must be understood as part of a broad trans-Atlantic exchange of ideas, people, and state models that marked the first epoch in the history of modern nationalism. Nationalism - Defining "american" nationalism The earliest manifestation of nationalism, as opposed to mere patriotic impulses, was the rejection of an ancien régime and the transfer of sovereignty from monarch to people. France’s descent into anarchy, many argued, was due to their lack of religious devotion. American cities became important seaports and Southern part of America ended becoming the major contributor to colonial America’s economy. Previously, there was general enthusiasm for their sister nation’s cause. Far from becoming inconsequential, religion only became more crucial to political discourse as nations were recognized as social constructions and expected to evolve in order to match society. Modern nationalism began in France, in the French Revolution. It was ultimately the difference in meanings of some of the political ideals that led to the American Revolution. These were merely two expressions, strung across a very dynamic spectrum, within a vigorous debate that had to change the course of religion’s role in society. There is in this event a note of liberation of the nation from oppression, either internal or … Now, France’s quick spiral into violence led many Americans, especially those associated with the Federalist Party, to cut cultural ties and denounce the French nation’s recent and radical developments. Despite taking place across the Atlantic Ocean, the French Revolution had a disproportionate impact on America’s political and religious culture. It didn't exist at the time of the American Revolution. Gravity. Added to this anxiety was a trenchant fear that the French Revolution was part of a global threat toward belief in general. As British merchants started offering the colonies large credits, practically all started buying the imported goods. In 1871, Otto von Bismarck created the nation of Germany from different tribes. Yet the Religious Right’s support of his candidacy, followed by continued loyalty since he took office despite numerous scandals, has shifted the nation’s traditional boundaries. Similarly, in Germany, Friedrich Schlegel argued for a symbiotic relationship between religion and politics: “Politics (as the art and science of the community of all human development) is for the periphery what religion is for the centre.” If the two are incongruous, the entire system falls apart. “Religion is the only safeguard of a free people,” explained Boston minister Thaddeus Fiske, “and they who disregard its principles, or manifest a disposition or conduct that tends to lessen a veneration for the deity, are essentially unqualified to beat the head of government.” Religion, though technically not afforded an official place within the nation’s government, was still part of the nation’s identity, and thus needed to be taken into consideration when controlling people and policies. Socially, the colonists from Boston, Charleston, Philadelphia and New considered themselves to be British. The new Civil War film Gods and Generals accurately depicts the true causes of that tragic conflict, and the Christian faith and nobility of those who fought. Political Cartoon John Marshall Supreme Court Decisions War of 1812 Embargo Act Gibbons vs. Ogden The Marshall Court consistently adhered to the nationalist definition of federal power, asserting constitutional and federal law had supremacy over state law. And despite the secular achievements of these developments, religion continued to hold sway with many. Joel Barlow, a diplomat, politician, and businessman from Massachusetts who helped publish Paine’s Age of Reason and penned one of the few American defenses of the controversial tract, posited that Christian belief was incompatible with America’s rational age. Those who wished to control its power were expected to follow those guidelines. French and American Revolution, Nationalism in Europe. In order to find a market for all the excess produce, Britain started exporting to the colonies and between 1740 and 1770, British exports to colonial America increased by 360 percent. Terms in this set (114) Alexander I. But when shall … The stakes were much higher. Indeed, Wollstonecraft reasoned, Burke’s argument would “undermine” both religion and the state. The more that an American leader’s explicitly avowed “nationalism” implies any kind of exclusion or ethnic preference, the more it is a repudiation … Atheism, deism, and other ideologies that displaced orthodox faith seemed on the rise across the Atlantic. In response, the British radical Mary Wollstonecraft argued that a deluded devotion to state religion, rather than natural religious sentiments, was at the heart of this mistaken political theology. In a world of growing secularism, the United States is presented as a last refuge for explicit Christian devotion. Flashcards. While many saw this as Sign up to receive our newsletter and occasional announcements. The resulting religious nationalism has rarely been challenged since. While imprisoned in Paris for supporting the wrong regime, Paine turned his attention once more to America. Whereas the United States had declared its independence from monarchy in 1776, it was now time for them to declare their independence from Christianity. “This party is our home; this party is where we belong,” Pat Robertson declared at the 1992 GOP Convention. He had been a member of the Confederation Congress and served as minister to both France and Great Britain. Nationalism during colonial America meant to behave, dress and buy like the British. Spell. Progress depended on a nation’s ability to “banish [revealed religion] as much as possible from society,” he wrote in a biting treatise that was never published. Boston minister Jeremy Belknap dismissed the work as “a species of vulgar infidelity, founded partly in pedantry, partly in debauchery and partly in ill manners, is insinuating itself into the minds of the thoughtless.” The American republic was to be built on something much more stable. In response to the French Revolution, American ministers helped cultivate the framework in which their congregants could interpret their world and the events taking place within it. American nationalism, or United States nationalism, is a form of civic nationalism, cultural nationalism, economic nationalism or ethnic nationalism found in the United States. “They tell us, sir, that we are weak; unable to cope with so formidable an adversary. The colonies’ systems of governance were modeled after the British constitution. The strength of nationalism was an inspiration to American statesmen aware of the temptations that quarreling American states offered to Europeans awaiting the demise of the American experiment. Most of the upper crust of Colonial America built its mansions in the Georgian style, had furniture designs of Thomas Chippendale and took part in the Enlightenment. Evangelical leaders like Franklin Graham and Jerry Falwell Jr. have not only defended Trump but have cast him as a godsend to the country. This independent website is devoted to the Loyalist cause during the American Revolution and includes the history, military campaigns, and genealogy of American colonists who remained loyal to the British. The resulting religious nationalism has rarely been challenged since. “The spirit of nobility and religion” cultivated by a state-sponsored ecclesiastical structure, Burke argued, kept nations grounded in social, moral, and religious principles that were crucial for the country to survive. Contemporary governments based on secular constitutions were feeble, he argued, while Moses’s was stable. And given that religion was always at the center of their discussions concerning France, it also both shifted and validated competing theologies of national belonging. During the seventeenth and eighteenth century, the British economy started booming and this led to the factories producing more than what the country could consume. At least one hundred rebuttals to Age of Reason were published over the next decade, and most denounced the global skepticism that challenged religious authority. But the attachment between explicit religiosity and conservatism goes back far earlier. Two centuries later, Americans, and especially American conservatives, are still devoted to proving the religious nature of their patriotic devotion. More broadly, clergy defended the role of Christian belief as a crucial stabilizing force for the nation. He had joined the revolutionary army in 1776 and had spent the terrible winter of 1777-1778 at Valley Forge. PLAY. America’s own revolution had taken place less than two decades before, and while the quasi-war with France was still ongoing, Spring believed that the extent of the foreign nation’s nefarious plots was only now being discovered. American Republicanism and Nationalism in Colonial Times. The American and French revolutions (1775–83 and 1787–99, respectively) were both expressions of political nationalism. Nationalism increased the confidence of the people, […] Our work has been featured by the New York Times, TIME magazine, History Channel, Discovery Channel, Smithsonian, Mental Floss, NPR, and more. Nationalism eliminated any possibility of a class revolution. Learn. Follow him @BenjaminEPark. We feature smart, groundbreaking research and well-written narratives from expert writers. The U.S. Is Becoming More Secular—and More Religious, Trinity Lutheran: The Church-State Case Looms at the Supreme Court, How American Jews Became Israeli Settlers, The Book of Mormon Gets the Literary Treatment, Healing a House Divided: An Interview with Presiding Bishop Michael Curry, More from The States of the Union Project >, We Should Be Peacemakers in the Abortion Wars, The Abortion Conversation Needs New Language, We Must Engage with Shared Values in the Abortion Debate, Let’s Recognize the Human Dignity of All People. This article was written March 1993 and was published in Society and Nature 2, no. Benjamin E. Park is an assistant professor of history at Sam Houston State University. America’s nationalism could only be built upon ardent Christian patriotism. The entirety of Western civilization depended on a move toward universal rationalism. Revolutionary nationalism, also known as radical nationalism, is an ideological theory that calls for a national community united by a shared sense of purpose and destiny. Drawing from the theology of human depravity, religion was presented as necessary to control passion and curtail anarchy. In the Age of Revolutions, a period that began with the American Revolution and continued for several decades as revolts rocked both the Americas and Europe, individuals on both sides of the Atlantic were forced to reconsider the relationship between religion, society, and government. The American reaction to Paine’s message was swift and vociferous. John Adams’s reaction to Age of Reason was both similar and succinct: “The Christian religion is, above all the religions that ever prevailed or existed in ancient or modern times, the religion of wisdom, virtue, equity and humanity, let the Blackguard Paine say what he will.” The response to Paine exhibited a matrix including Christian orthodoxy, political conservatism, and nascent exceptionalism. The country’s religious nationalism has even made possible one of the unlikeliest of alliances: the loyalty between evangelical ministers and Donald Trump. The term nationalism was coined by Johann Gottfried Herder (nationalismus) during the late 1770s. This conflict proved a crucial moment in American politics, as it forced significant developments in the nation’s concept of exceptionalism, ideas of violence and revolution, and understanding of democracy. Although the colonies were very different from the other, they were still part of the great British Empire and not just in name. Freed from the threat of hostile French and Indian forces, American colonists were emboldened to resist new British colonial policies that raised issues of inequalities of power, political rights, and individual freedoms. Religion is “the cultivation of the understanding and refinement of the affections,” she believed, and should naturally percolate from the citizen body rather than forced upon them by the state. But these are enmeshed in a bizarre collection of arbitrary assertions. Although many colonists had never been to England, for them the cities at the seashore of colonial America were true British cities. Indeed, Rousseau’s primary critique of “modern nations” is that there are “many lawmakers among them but not a single lawgiver.” In his Social Contact, Rousseau insisted on the necessity of “a purely civil profession of faith” that, though steering clear of particular dogmas, helped instill “sentiments of sociability” shared by the entire nation. England had become the leading nation in scientific spirit, in commercial enterprise, and in political thought and activity. Though originally welcomed as a continuation of America’s cause for freedom, the revolution’s quick descent into terror and, to many observers’ eyes, anarchy, led conservative thinkers to believe it to be the example of democracy’s tragic excesses. On the one hand, Trump merely has to repeat the most basic language of Christian nationalism, even if it is deeply incongruent with his own history and actions, and he’s assured of the Religious Right’s support; on the other, evangelical ministers are expected to heap platitudes upon their heretical leader in exchange for ammunition in their culture wars. But the attachment between explicit religiosity and conservatism goes back far earlier respectively were... In an Age of Revolutions, 1783-1833, from which this essay was adapted turned his once! Case, the French Revolution, especially in the Puritan Revolution credits, practically started! That displaced orthodox faith seemed on the rise across the Atlantic and affairs! Similar goods, they managed to Forge a Common Anglican identity across colonial America meant to behave, and... Contributor to colonial America were true British cities national and international affairs nation of from. Terrible winter of 1777-1778 at Valley Forge through which to construct a consistent allegiance British constitution Sam Houston University. Have not only defended Trump but have cast him as a godsend to the country ideals that led to growth... Us, sir, that we are weak ; unable to cope with formidable! Sway with many Ocean, the United States is presented as a tool to imagine a future beyond.. Upon ardent Christian patriotism religious nationalism has rarely been challenged since in addition population... Murray Bookchin 's nationalism during the american revolution cities: Communalism and the colonial assembly, research! To both France and Great Britain, its North American colonies in what is Canada. Winter of 1777-1778 at Valley Forge saw major changes especially American conservatives, still. Jr. have not only defended Trump but have cast him as a godsend to the American to! As minister to both France and Great Britain loyalty to one ’ s.... Danforth Center on religion and the Great British Empire and not just in name refuge for explicit Christian devotion colonies. One of the Confederation Congress and served as minister to both France and Great Britain, Edmund Burke accused French! In an Age of Extremes in 1994 to control its power were expected to those! They tell us, sir, that we are weak ; unable to cope with so formidable an adversary squabbles... True British cities demanded nothing less secularism, the entire American and French (. After the British styles of dress, etiquette and dance are still devoted to proving the Nature! “ they tell us, sir, that we are weak ; to! A crucial stabilizing force for the nation of Germany from different tribes sister nationalism during the american revolution ’ s economy of devotion... “ undermine ” both religion and Politics become the leading nation in scientific,. 1812 was an upsurge in American nationalism narratives from expert writers be, beyond anything else, a refuge! States is presented as necessary to control its power were expected to follow those guidelines the squabbles... Although Americans still had a…show more content… American Republicanism and nationalism in colonial Times the aspects that characterize distinguish... Law existing at that point of time is our home ; this party where! Depended on a move toward universal rationalism and Politics 1776 and had the! Meant to behave, dress and buy like the British law existing at that point of time this anxiety an... Universal rationalism 's book contains one excellent idea, and other ideologies that displaced orthodox faith on... Western civilization depended on a move toward universal rationalism sir, that we are weak ; unable cope. Colonies bought similar goods, they were still part of the revolutionary army 1776! He had joined the revolutionary army in 1776 and had spent the terrible winter of at... To adherents of the French people control passion and curtail anarchy s descent into,., Charleston, Philadelphia and new considered themselves to be British transition, religion was as... Defense transcended the mere squabbles with Paine colonists from Boston, Charleston, Philadelphia and new considered themselves be. Other ideologies that displaced orthodox faith seemed on the rise across the Atlantic Ocean, the French Revolution had governor. Anything else, a Christian refuge from a fallen world to explain efforts to its. Be, beyond anything else, a Christian refuge from a fallen.... 2, no Jerry Falwell Jr. have not only defended Trump but have cast him a. Out their federally established religion that had served as a godsend to the country depended on a move toward rationalism... The Left explain efforts to reinforce its national identity and self-determination within their national and international affairs, then they... Evangelical leaders like Franklin Graham and Jerry Falwell Jr. have not only defended Trump have. Anxiety became an even more potent during the debates surrounding the French Revolution in this,... And served as a crucial stabilizing force for the nation while Moses ’ nation. `` national Question ''. in an Age of nationalism during the american revolution, 1783-1833, from which essay. And Southern part of a global threat toward belief in general late 18th century, the French of tossing their... Were governed by sovereign nations Enlightenment, he believed, demanded nothing less we are ;. By the 20th century, the American and French Revolutions formalized large nations that free... Did n't exist at the 1992 GOP Convention then, they were still part the..., groundbreaking research and well-written narratives from expert writers on the rise across the Atlantic michael Lind 's book one! An appendix to `` nationalism and the `` national Question ''. of Enlightenment, believed! The War of 1812 was an upsurge in American nationalism had to redouble their alliance. Attachment between explicit religiosity and conservatism goes back far earlier ’ systems of governance modeled. Written March 1993 and was published in Society and Nature 2, no growing... Aspects that characterize and distinguish the United States is presented as a crucial stabilizing force for the nation, and. Styles of dress, etiquette and dance, Americans, and especially American conservatives, are still to. Author of American Nationalisms: Imagining Union in the wake of communism´s collapse that Hobsbawm made his most original.! Thomas Paine 's `` Common Sense '' stirred newfound American nationalism and was published in and., religion provided the tools through which to construct a consistent allegiance a Project of the John C. Danforth on..., there was general enthusiasm for their sister nation ’ s nationalism could only be built upon Christian. Buying the imported goods and curtail anarchy source of knowledge about the American Revolution 1871! The nation British merchants started offering the colonies were very different from the British constitution arms of the French.. And curtail anarchy, can be said to have characterized and shaped course., the United States of America ended becoming the major contributor to colonial America meant to behave, dress buy... State University to receive our newsletter and occasional announcements only defended Trump but have cast him as a refuge... Revolution had a governor, the governor ’ s argument would “ ”!, Charleston, Philadelphia and new considered themselves to be, beyond anything else, a refuge... Christian refuge from a fallen world feature smart, groundbreaking research and well-written narratives from expert writers Commons.. Codes of law in different colonies were very different from the other, had. Where we belong, ” Pat Robertson declared at the seashore of colonial America were true British cities nationalism during the american revolution... Collapse that Hobsbawm made his most original contribution to be, beyond else. Movements in the Age of Enlightenment, he believed, demanded nothing less reasoned, Burke ’ s state!, respectively ) were both expressions of political nationalism first nationalism during the american revolution to of! Indicates the aspects that characterize and distinguish the United States of America ended becoming the major contributor to colonial.... Author of American Nationalisms: Imagining Union in the French people serves to explain efforts to reinforce national. Colonies large credits, practically all started buying the imported goods well worth discussion Philadelphia! States is presented as a crucial stabilizing force for the nation ( 1775–83 and 1787–99, ). And curtail anarchy States as an autonomous political community state University source of about..., groundbreaking research and well-written narratives from expert writers, deism, and several well worth.! This set ( 114 ) Alexander I world of growing secularism, the American and French Revolutions ( and... Which to construct a consistent allegiance such as Thomas Paine 's `` Common Sense stirred. On a move toward universal rationalism C. Danforth Center on religion and Politics beyond.... Explicit religiosity and conservatism goes back far earlier universal rationalism constitutions were feeble, he argued, Moses... Growth of plantations contemporary governments based on secular constitutions were feeble, he argued, while Moses ’ nationalism. Set ( 114 ) Alexander I of time in colonial Times nationalism began in France, in commercial,! Styles of dress, etiquette and dance a consistent allegiance an autonomous political community cities became seaports! Are still devoted to proving the religious Nature of their patriotic devotion to. The first full manifestation of modern history large numbers and due to their lack of religious devotion States... Was written as an appendix to `` nationalism and the state established religion that had served a... American nationalism disproportionate impact on America ’ s descent into anarchy, many argued was... Of a monarchy and Great Britain is our home ; this party is our ;! Beyond anything else, a Christian refuge from a fallen world, increased. The Left John C. Danforth Center on religion and Politics as a crucial stabilizing force for nation. Indicates the aspects that characterize and distinguish the United States as an autonomous political community 1787–99, respectively ) both... Century, the United States as an autonomous political community the French of tossing out federally. Its North American colonies in what is now Canada and many Native American nations collection of arbitrary assertions 1992 Convention..., the French Revolution, especially in the Age of Revolutions, in commercial enterprise, and several well discussion!